Home Television Television Episode Blog TV FLASHBACK: American Idol Season 8 Revisited
TV FLASHBACK: American Idol Season 8 Revisited
Written by US Townhall staff   
Tuesday, 26 January 2010 04:05

American Idol Finals - Week 3 Performances 3/25/09

Because of the press conference by President Obama on Tuesday, this week's American Idol competition was delayed by a day with the performances taking place on Wednesday and the results being given tonight, Thursday, March 26 at 8pm.

Last night's performances were centered around the songs of Motown and founder Berry Gordy and Motown legend Smokey Robinson were in the audience. Robinson also served as this week's mentor to the kids. This isn't the first time we've had Motown week on American Idol, and just as in the past, last night's results were uneven. A few contestants really shone brightly, but most were either mediocre or overwhelmed by the source material.

Here's a recap of what happened last night along with our predictions of who is in danger of being in the bottom 3.

(1) Matt Giraud sang "Let's Get it On" by Marvin Gaye. Matt received universal praise for his rendition from the judges who proclaimed him to be one of the frontrunners, presumably joining Danny Gokey and Adam Lambert. We liked this performance too, and it was nice to see Matt step away from the piano and work the audience because this particular song demanded that type of closer connection. Absolutely in no danger of being in the bottom 3 tonight. PREDICTION: SAFE

(2) Kris Allen sang "How Sweet it Is (To Be Loved by You)" by Marvin Gaye. Kris accompanied himself on the acoustic guitar for his version fo the 1964 classic. This could easily have been a trainwreck, but Kris's strong vocals and lively performance won us over and he received positive notes from all the judges. Simon asked Kris to have more confidence, conceit, and "swagger," but we don't feel that's necessary as Kris seems very confident and comfortable in his performances. He proved last week he can give a memorable vocal without hiding behind his guitar, and while he hasn't gotten the same level of buzz as Adam or Danny, Kris is so dependable and reliable in terms of entertaining the audience that he's clearly one to keep watching. PREDICTION: SAFE

(3) Scott MacIntyre sang "You Can't Hurry Love" by The Supremes. Scott actually has one of the better voices in the competition. However, Paula was right in that using the piano each week makes his performances all seem very similar to each other. This makes him very identifiable, which is a good thing of course, but given that this is a competition where there is an extra level of scrutiny on the singers, it doesn't lead to the most visually interesting performances. The judges have become increasingly critical of him, and we agree that if he does feel the need to stay behind the piano, he might have done better by not choosing this uptempo song and instead gone for a more soulful, emotional number. However, Scott still has much goodwill built up with the audience so even if he does land in the bottom 3, there's no way he will be sent home. PREDICTION: BOTTOM 3

(4) Megan Joy sang "For Once in My Life" by (among others) Stevie Wonder. The first unmitigated trainwreck of the night, Megan received pans from all the judges, and we'd have to agree. She was off-key a number of times throughout the song, and in general the arrangement was inappropriate for her voice and vocal stylings. We'd agree with Kara that "My Guy" by Mary Wells would have been a much better fit for Megan and possibly allowed her to show off a more flirty side as her performances have become too similar to each other over the weeks. PREDICTION: BOTTOM 3

(5) Anoop Desai sang "Ooo Baby Baby" by The Miracles. Anoop took a risk in singing a song by Smokey Robinson himself, but the risk paid off. Anoop delivered a great vocal and his voice fit perfectly within the key of Robinson's original vocals with very little change being necessary. We had a problem with the judges' critiques because they were damning him with faint praise, which often leaves the audience feeling ambivalent toward a contestant where they should be left feeling more enthusiastic about such a good performance. These kinds of critiques led to the departure of Jasmine Murray before her time, and we hope the same thing doesn't happen here. PREDICTION: SAFE

(6) Michael Sarver sang "Ain't Too Proud to Beg" by The Temptations. Sarver interpreted this song incorrectly with a lot of smiling and working the crowd on what is supposed to be a more desperate, pleading number. It wasn't a bad vocal, but it was emotionally flat and had a hotel lounge singer feel to it. There's really not much more that can be said about this except that once again, we feel that Michael will land in the bottom 3. PREDICTION: BOTTOM 3

(7) Lil Rounds sang "(Love is Like a) Heat Wave" by Martha and the Vandellas. Lil powered through the song as she always does, but we'd agree with the judges in that the song was too uptempo for her and didn't show off the strengths of her voice. A few times during the performance, she was on the verge of losing her breath, and the fact that the song began at a high energy level and remained that way throughout did not allow Lil to show off her vocal range and bring any emotion or nuance to her performance. We're hoping that Lil still has enough goodwill built up with the audience that she avoids the bottom 3, but we wouldn't be surprised to see her there. PREDICTION: SAFE

(8) Adam Lambert sang "The Tracks of My Tears" by The Miracles. Just like Anoop, Adam sang a Smokey Robinson song, but unlike Anoop, he changed the song in such a way that he had "a moment," as Simon would put it. Following a standing ovation by Smokey himself, Kara began her criticism with the mathematical gaffe of the series by saying "I got 6 words for you: One of the best performances of the night." That aside, the praise was well deserved for this tender, pulled-back performance from Adam, who had grated on us in the past with over-the-top caterwauling. If Adam were in any danger after last week's polarizing rendition of "Ring of Fire," he wiped all that away and catapulted himself back to front runner status. His risks don't always pay off with everyone, but he is interesting to watch because you never know quite what you are going to get with him from week to week, yet the results do somehow make sense in the context of who he is as an artist. PREDICTION: SAFE and once again, possibly the highest vote getter of the night.

(9) Danny Gokey sang "Get Ready" by The Temptations. Another song written by Smokey himself, Danny curiously ignored Smokey's suggestion that Danny sing the background vocal echo, but still delivered a solid performance. It was powerful, energetic, and much better than the quick put down that Simon gave it. The other judges gave it better reviews, and the studio audience loved it as well. In our estimation, it was one of the better vocals and performances of the night, and with Adam's, a lock to be one of the highest vote getters. PREDICTION: SAFE

(10) Allison Iraheta sang "Papa Was a Rollin' Stone" by The Temptations (although it was originally, and unsuccessfully, recorded by The Undisputed Truth). Inexplicably in the bottom 3 last week, Allison gave a gritty, powerful vocal on this classic. Having the advantage of going last, she would definitely be memorable in the minds of the voters and after great reviews by the four judges and a standing ovation by Smokey, Berry, and the audience, Allison should have no trouble staying out of the bottom 3 this week. There are only 3 ladies left in the competition at this point, and Allison clearly gave the vocal of the night on the female side. PREDICTION: SAFE

We correctly predicted that Alexis would be going home last week, so let's see if we can extend our winning streak. Based on last night's performances, we'd pick the bottom 3 as Megan Joy, Michael Sarver, and possibly Scott MacIntyre. We're very confident in our choices of Megan and Michael, but less so on Scott. If the last of the bottom 3 were either Anoop Desai (based solely on the judges' tepid praise) or Lil Rounds, we wouldn't be shocked, but neither of them should be in any real danger of going home. Certainly, if Lil Rounds were the bottom vote getter, we could easily see the "Judge's Save" being employed to veto that result.

However, if things go the way they should, it will probably be Michael or Megan going home tonight. Given that Michael has consistently underwhelmed us thus far, we'd send him packing.

Remember, that tonight's results show airs at 8pm Eastern rather than the usual 9pm. Musical highlights will include a duet by Smokey Robinson and Joss Stone, American Idol Season 2 winner Ruben Studdard, and a Motown medley by Stevie Wonder.



 

MORE INTERVIEWS...

  

the-apprentice-logo-thumb UslanMichael-resize-thumb 30-rock-thumb agnes-nixon-thumb BenSpierman-thumb big-brother-logo-thumb bobby-flay-thumb Bridgeboy-logo-thumb
cast of The Apprentice 10

BATMAN film producer MICHAEL USLAN

Sherri Shepherd

Vanessa Minnillo

All My Children creator AGNES NIXON

Bronx Opera's BEN SPIERMAN

cast of Big Brother 12 BOBBY FLAY & STEVE ELLS of America's Next Great Restaurant Cast of the play Bridgeboy
bruce-canwell-thumb chuck-thumb crystal-chappell-thumb dan-kroll-thumb dan-parent-thumb david-lyons-thumb debbie-gibson-tiffany-thumb dede-emerson-thumb
Library of American Comics' BRUCE CANWELL RYAN McPARTLIN & SARAH LANCASTER

CRYSTAL CHAPPELL

part 1: Guiding Light

part 2: Days of Our Lives

soapcentral.com founder DAN KROLL DAN PARENT of Archie Comics DAVID LYONS of The Cape DEBBIE GIBSON & TIFFANY Author DEDE EMERSON of A Different Kind of Streetwalker
dowling_jpeg-thumb eliana-ujueta-thumb jamal-igle-thumb Jay-Mary-thumb jeremy-irons-thumb jerry-beck-thumb josh-groban-thumb kai-soremekun-thumb
BOB DOWLING of the 3D Entertainment Summit Indie filmmaker ELIANA UJUETA of Beneath the Rock comic book artist JAMAL IGLE Genesis Repertory's JAY MICHAELS, MARY MiCARI, & actors Oscar-winning actor JEREMY IRONS

Animation historian JERRY BECK

1st interview

2nd interview

singer-songwriter JOSH GROBAN

web series producer KAI SOREMEKUN of Chick

1st interview

2nd interview

kathy-bates-thumb kenneth-johnson-thumb kyle-bornheimer-thumb law-and-order-los-angeles-thumb logo-thumb luann-de-lesseps-thumb max-thumb mike-miz-thumb
Oscar-winning actress KATHY BATES of Harry's Law Television producer KENNETH JOHNSON of V, Bionic Woman, Incredible Hulk KYLE BORNHEIMER & HAYES MacARTHUR of Perfect Couples

Terrence Howard, René Balcer

Dick Wolf, Alfred Molina, Alana de la Garza

publisher DAN HERMAN of Hermes Press COUNTESS LuANN de LESSEPS of The Real Housewives of New York City author MAX ALLAN COLLINS of Road to Perdition WWE Champion Mike "The MIz" Mizanin
MillCreeklogo-thumb nick-lachey-thumb niki-taylor-thumb paul-reiser-thumb ricky-gervais-thumb rosie-odonnell-thumb steve-niles-thumb the-event-cast-logo-thumb

JEFF HAYNE of Mill Creek Entertainment

1st interview

2nd interview

singer-actor NICK LACHEY supermodel NIKI TAYLOR talks The Celebrity Apprentice actor PAUL REISER of The Paul Reiser Show actor-producer RICKY GERVAIS of The Office actress-television host ROSIE O'DONNELL comic book writer STEVE NILES

Ian Anthony Dale, Nick Wauters

Jason Ritter, Sarah Roemer, Blair Underwood, Željko Ivanek

thore-jo-thumb tom-brokaw-thumb tom-pelphrey-thumb apothecary-theatre-thumb tori-spelling-thumb
THORE SCHÖLERMANN & JO WEIL of Verbotene Liebe Peabody & Emmy award winning journalist TOM BROKAW Emmy award winning actor TOM PELPHREY of Guiding Light actors from The Apothecary Theatre Company TORI SPELLING & DEAN McDERMOTT of sTORIbook Weddings

 

 

MORE FEATURES... 

 

Reviews & Previews:

Summer 2011 Movie Preview

Fall 2010 Television season

Fra Diavolo

Die Drei Pintos

Romeo and Juliet in Brooklyn

MPI Home Video

Timless Media Group

Boris Karloff's Thriller

Hunter: The Complete Series

Polly and Her Pals

Icons: The DC Comics and Wildstorm Art of Jim Lee

Adrianne Palicki as Wonder Woman

Ryan Reynolds as Green Lantern

Spider-Man musical delayed again

Frozen

Dead Space: Aftermath

Altitude

 

 

    

Events:

New York Comic Con

Apprentice 10 kickoff

Farewell to Guiding Light

Farewell to As the World Turns

The Broadway Directory

 

Award Show winners:

Academy Awards

Emmy Awards

Grammy Awards

Tony Awards

American Music Awards

Golden Globe Awards

Screen Actors Guild Awards

American Country Awards

 

    

Television blogs:

American Idol 10

American Idol 9

American Idol 8

Big Brother 12

Big Brother 11

ABC Cancels Both All My Children and One Life to Live

Guiding Light: A Look Back

 

Editorials & Issues:

Scam Alert: Have You Received This E-Mail Job Offer?

Meet the 112th Congress

Brooklyn politicians Kevin Peter Carroll vs. Ralph Perfetto

Before Rosa Parks There Was Lizzie Jennings

Understanding New York State Government

USTownhall RoundTable podcast: The Worlds of Entertainment and Current Events